MLB ALDS Best Bets: Expert MLB Picks for Saturday, October 12

Matthew Boyd will be a key figure in today's ALDS Game 5 contest between the Tigers and the Guardians. Michael Rathburn shares his expert MLB picks for this series-clinching matchup.
MLB ALDS Best Bets: Expert MLB Picks for Saturday, October 12

MLB Draft Kit

Prepare for your baseball season with RotoWire's MLB Draft Kit including rankings, auction value support, and mock draft simulator.

MLB Divisional Series Bets: Expert MLB Picks for Saturday, October 12

  • Year-to-Date Record: 175-174-1
  • Prior Article: 4-1 (+2.5 units)

Get the most lucrative sportsbook promos from your favorite sports betting apps and boost your bankroll today. The BetMGM bonus code offers new users a first-bet bonus worth up to $1,500.

MLB Postseason Betting Tips

PITCHING IMPACT

A lower run-scoring environment means you want to focus on under run totals, pitcher hits allowed and over strikeouts. Avoid laying -1.5 runs unless it is an extreme situation. 

BULLPEN USAGE

You need to check bullpen usage for each team before making your plays. The starting pitching represents about 55 percent of the game in the regular season. In the postseason it goes down as teams have a day off between games. Bullpens are critical to postseason success and should be heavily taken into consideration.

HITTER PROPS

Be careful with hitter props because every team is throwing their best pitchers. We are dealing with some of the best MLB teams. I will look only at home run + runs + RBI props on a top-four hitter in the playoffs. 

Don't make any bets on the best online sportsbooks without first making sure you are making informed bets by having the latest MLB odds at your fingertips.

MLB Unit Betting Guide

Here is a basic guideline I use when it comes to betting on baseball and knowing what unit value to place on each bet:

  • 1.5 - 2.0 units (Best Bets - typically a full game total or ML/RL play)
  • 1 unit (Moneyline/Run Line/Totals Strongest Plays, System Plays)
  • 0.75 unit (ML/RL/Totals Medium Plays, Pitcher Props – Ks, Outs; F5)
  • 0.50 unit (Pitcher Props – Earned Runs; Hitter Props – TB, HRRBI; Team Totals, F5 Run Line/Totals)
  • 0.25 unit (Parlays, HR Props, Alt Props)

Detroit Tigers at Cleveland Guardians  

This has been a great series, but offensively challenged, to say the least. Game 5 should be exciting, though, with Tarik Skubal facing Matthew Boyd. Skubal has been the best pitcher in the American League and lights out in the playoffs. He is much better at home than on the road, however. Matthew Boyd is being overlooked here as he has been strong in his last seven starts.

The Guardians are also significantly better at home and have the better bullpen/closer.

I can not see Skubal going fewer than six innings in this game as the Tigers need him desperately but the juice on his over recorded outs prop is -190. 

Ultimately, I like the Guardians to take the series. At plus-money, as a home underdog, there is value here. I am staying away from the full game under because as home underdogs the Guardians have put up runs. I think the Guardians get to the Tigers' bullpen late. 

Best MLB Picks for Tigers at Guardians

  • Guardians Moneyline for 1 Unit (+105 at BetRivers)
  • Tigers Team Total Under 0.5 Runs F3 for 1 Unit (-105 at DraftKings Sportsbook)

Don't miss out on the best MLB picks and props with RotoWire's picks tool

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Known as “Rath” in the Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS) community, he has helped run operations for two prominent daily fantasy sports startups. Michael has taken his insider knowledge and expertise in daily fantasy sports to the content side. Rath won the 2016 FSWA "Baseball Article of the Year, Online" award and was a finalist for the FSWA Best Baseball Series in 2011.
RotoWire Logo

Continue the Conversation

Join the RotoWire Discord group to hear from our experts and other MLB fans.

Top News

  • Milwaukee Brewers
    Brandon Woodruff
    Opening Day 'up in the air'
    MLB
    Milwaukee Brewers
  • Los Angeles Dodgers
    Blake Snell
    Status for Opening Day uncertain
    MLB
    Los Angeles Dodgers
  • Texas Rangers
    Josh Smith
    Favorite for second base job
    MLB
    Texas Rangers
  • Kansas City Royals
    Maikel Garcia
    Pair of hits from leadoff spot
    MLB
    Kansas City Royals
  • Cleveland Guardians
    Jose Ramirez
    Tallies four RBI in spring game
    MLB
    Cleveland Guardians

Tools

MLB Draft Kit Logo

MLB Draft Kit

Fantasy Tools

Don’t miss a beat. Check out our 2026 MLB Fantasy Baseball rankings.

Related Stories