The Stats Room: Analyzing the Impact of a Holdout

The Stats Room: Analyzing the Impact of a Holdout

This article is part of our The Stats Room series.

Le'Veon Bell continues to hold out. The reasons behind him not reporting is for some talking head to cover. What I'm here to investigate is the impact holding out will have on his production when he finally does report. And the impact is substantial.

To find the impact on Bell's production, I needed a list of previous holdouts to compare their production. The skill position list was shorter than expected. I was hoping to split out players by position and holdout length but no such luck. After digging around on the internet and asking around, I came up with the following player list.

Joey Galloway 1999
Larry Johnson 2007
Steven Jackson 2008
Michael Crabtree 2009
Vincent Jackson 2010
Chris Johnson 2011
Maurice Jones-Drew 2012
Marshawn Lynch 2014
Vernon Davis 2014
Andre Johnson 2014
Dez Bryant 2015
Demaryius Thomas 2015
DeAndre Hopkins 2016
Le'Veon Bell 2017

I started comparing their holdout season to their previous season and quickly ran into a roadblock. These players were coming off great seasons. They wanted a payday for previous season's work. I don't blame them.

The problem with coming off a great season, owners need to account for some regression. I removed tight end Vernon Davis and found the players averaged 222 fantasy points (non-PPR) in the season prior to their holdout.

Looking from 1990 to present, I found the wide receivers and running backs who posted 200-240 fantasy points. Then, I found their next season's production. The players fantasy stats declined by 23 percent

Le'Veon Bell continues to hold out. The reasons behind him not reporting is for some talking head to cover. What I'm here to investigate is the impact holding out will have on his production when he finally does report. And the impact is substantial.

To find the impact on Bell's production, I needed a list of previous holdouts to compare their production. The skill position list was shorter than expected. I was hoping to split out players by position and holdout length but no such luck. After digging around on the internet and asking around, I came up with the following player list.

Joey Galloway 1999
Larry Johnson 2007
Steven Jackson 2008
Michael Crabtree 2009
Vincent Jackson 2010
Chris Johnson 2011
Maurice Jones-Drew 2012
Marshawn Lynch 2014
Vernon Davis 2014
Andre Johnson 2014
Dez Bryant 2015
Demaryius Thomas 2015
DeAndre Hopkins 2016
Le'Veon Bell 2017

I started comparing their holdout season to their previous season and quickly ran into a roadblock. These players were coming off great seasons. They wanted a payday for previous season's work. I don't blame them.

The problem with coming off a great season, owners need to account for some regression. I removed tight end Vernon Davis and found the players averaged 222 fantasy points (non-PPR) in the season prior to their holdout.

Looking from 1990 to present, I found the wide receivers and running backs who posted 200-240 fantasy points. Then, I found their next season's production. The players fantasy stats declined by 23 percent (median = 22 percent).

To determine the holdout's drop, I took their previous season's standard fantasy points and compared them to the next season. I broke up the next season by the first two, four and rest of season to see if the player comes in rusty (not really).

Note: I removed Crabtree from the list as he held out his rookie season.

PLAYERSEASONGFP/GFIRST GMTOTAL GMFIRST 2 GM
FP/G
FIRST 4 GM
FP/GM
ROS FP/G
Joey Galloway19991610.5985.36.33.6
Larry Johnson20071620.9198.79.012.5
Steven Jackson20081214.01128.213.316.5
Vincent Jackson20101511.513416.811.10.0
Chris Johnson20111614.41165.77.511.5
Maurice Jones-Drew20121616.11611.113.93.3
Marshawn Lynch20141615.011618.419.815.5
Vernon Davis20141610.111410.26.01.3
Andre Johnson20141610.71158.46.17.4
Dez Bryant20151614.3193.06.76.2
Demaryius Thomas20151614.41168.810.010.2
DeAndre Hopkins20161613.81169.46.27.9
Le'Veon Bell20171220.21156.912.618.8
Average15.314.32.512.09.39.98.8
Median15.314.62.012.39.610.19.2

As expected, the average fantasy points per game dropped, but the drop needs to be compared to the normal regression. Here are the median and average holdout percentages and the normal regression production declines.

EXPECTED DECLINEFIRST 2 GMDIFFFIRST 4 GMDIFFROSDIFF
Average23%31%8%41%18%37%14%
Median22%39%17%43%21%49%27%

These holdouts saw their production drop an additional 8 to 27 percent more than the normal regression with the average 17.5 percent. The drop is especially bad for the rest-of-season values. These players can't keep up their production as the season goes on.

These findings can fit several narratives. While the players likely worked out on their own, the workout is not as tough as the team's workouts. Second, and probably more important, the players had less time to gel with their teammates and find their offensive groove. No matter the exact reason, they performed worse than expected.

So, applying the research to Le'Veon Bell, he generated 256.6 fantasy points last season or an average of 17.1 points per game. With a ~22.5 percent regression decline and 17.5 percent from holding out, he's looking at 40 percent drop or 10.3 points per game. Some running backs who put up similar per game numbers in 2017 were Carlos Hyde, (10.9), Dion Lewis (10.3) and Rex Burkhead (10.0). Good but not top-flight running backs.

As soon as Bell's holdout was known and he started missing camp, his value should have dropped hard. I expect owners to remain hopeful for future holdouts, but they won't. Savvy owners will stay away from holdouts.

I was all-in with Bell coming into the season and own him in several leagues. After completing this research, I made the wrong decision. We are all here to learn and this lesson will be a hard pill to swallow. At least we can be more informed next season.

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only NFL Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire NFL fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jeff Zimmerman
Jeff is a former RotoWire contributor. He wrote analytics-focused baseball and football articles for RotoWire. He is a three-time FSWA award winner, including the Football Writer of the Year and Best Football Print Article awards in 2016. The 2017 Tout Wars Mixed Auction champion and 2016 Tout Wars Head-to-Head champ, Zimmerman also contributes to FanGraphs.com, BaseballHQ and Baseball America.
NFL Waiver Wire: Week 10 Pickups
NFL Waiver Wire: Week 10 Pickups
Target Breakdown: WR & TE Usage Report + Week 10 Waivers Preview
Target Breakdown: WR & TE Usage Report + Week 10 Waivers Preview
NFL Picks: NFL Key Line Moves for Week 10
NFL Picks: NFL Key Line Moves for Week 10
Backfield Breakdown: RB Usage Report & Week 10 Waivers Preview
Backfield Breakdown: RB Usage Report & Week 10 Waivers Preview