MLB Best Bets Today: MLB Betting Picks for Tuesday, May 12
Prior article 0-3 -2.50 units
Season 34-43 -8.91 units
Cash in on the best sportsbook promos available at the best MLB betting sites during the MLB playoffs. The BetMGM bonus code gets new players one of the best welcome bonuses in the industry.
Key MLB Betting Trends, Insights, and Matchups Analysis
Rotowire Betting Hub
(Odds, Starting Lineups, Batter v Pitcher, News, Weather, Bullpen Usage)
Make sure to check the latest odds and all sportsbooks, starting lineups, weather, batter vs pitcher, and bullpen usage before making any wagers.
Check out Caesars' MLB offerings this postseason using the Caesars Sportsbook promo code at signup for a generous welcome offer.
Tampa Bay Rays vs. Toronto Blue Jays Best Bets and Predictions
The Tampa Bay Rays (27-13), sitting atop the American League East, visit the struggling Toronto Blue Jays (18-23) for the second installment of a three-game series at Rogers Centre in Toronto, Ontario. First pitch is scheduled for 7:07 PM EDT. Both teams played Monday, with the Rays taking Game 1 by a score of 8-5. Tampa Bay has dominated the season series, winning all 4-0 matchups so far.
Pitching Matchup: Shane McClanahan vs Patrick Corbin
Tampa Bay Rays send left-hander Shane McClanahan (4-2, 2.60 ERA, 1.07 WHIP in 34.2 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 2.74, xFIP 3.20, xERA 3.57, K/BB% 14.2% (24.1% K-rate, 9.9% BB-rate). McClanahan continues to dominate with elite strikeout stuff.
Toronto Blue Jays counter with left-hander Patrick Corbin (1-1, 3.60 ERA, 1.27 WHIP in 30.0 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 4.32, xFIP 4.31, xERA 5.69, K/BB% 12.7% (16.9% K-rate, 7.3% BB-rate). Corbin has been serviceable but remains vulnerable to hard contact.
The two starters faced each other last week in a low-scoring Rays victory.
The Rays are red-hot at 9-1 in their last 10 games, while the Blue Jays have gone 4-6 over the same stretch.
Weather at Rogers Centre
Cool evening conditions around 55-58°F with the roof likely closed — no wind or weather impact, creating a neutral, pitcher-friendly indoor environment.
Betting Odds (Consensus)
- Moneyline: Rays -115 to -126 | Blue Jays +100 to +108
- Run Line: Rays -1.5 (+141) | Blue Jays +1.5 (-170)
- Total (Over/Under): Over 8 (-105) / Under 8 (-115)
Best Bet: Rays Moneyline
This Rays vs Blue Jays betting preview strongly recommends the Rays on the Moneyline (-120 to -126). McClanahan's superior advanced metrics create a clear pitching edge over Corbin in this rematch, while Tampa Bay's scorching form and 4-0 season-series dominance make them excellent value as road favorites.
Rays vs Blue Jays Prediction: Expect the Rays to keep rolling and extend their series lead. Lean Rays ML confidently as the top play today.
Best Bet: Rays ML for 1.0 unit (FanDuel -115)
Colorado Rockies vs. Pittsburgh Pirates Best Bets and Predictions
The Colorado Rockies (16-25) visit the Pittsburgh Pirates (22-19) for the series opener at PNC Park in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. First pitch is scheduled for 6:40 PM EDT. Both teams played yesterday, with the Pirates winning their previous series finale while the Rockies dropped theirs.
Pitching Matchup: Michael Lorenzen vs Paul Skenes
Colorado Rockies send right-hander Michael Lorenzen (2-4, 6.92 ERA, 1.90 WHIP in 39.0 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 5.27, xFIP 5.10, xERA 5.85, K/BB% 6.0% (6.0 K/9, 2.8 BB/9). Lorenzen has been hit hard consistently this season.
Pittsburgh Pirates counter with right-hander Paul Skenes (5-2, 2.36 ERA, 0.71 WHIP in 42.0 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 2.80, xFIP 2.95, xERA 3.10, K/BB% 22% (9.9 K/9, 1.5 BB/9). Skenes remains one of the most dominant starters in baseball.
The Pirates are 9-1 in their last 10 games, while the Rockies have gone 4-6 over the same stretch. While the Rockies have shown some improvement on the road, three of those wins came against the Mets — who currently hold the worst record in baseball. This represents a massive step up in class against the best pitcher in baseball in Paul Skenes.
Weather at PNC Park
Mild evening conditions around 60-64°F at first pitch, partly cloudy skies, and light winds (5-10 mph blowing in from left field). Low rain chance, creating a neutral-to-pitcher-friendly environment.
Betting Odds (Consensus)
- Moneyline: Pirates -330 to -350 | Rockies +270 to +290
- Run Line: Pirates -1.5 (-135 to -145) | Rockies +1.5 (+115 to +125)
- Total (Over/Under): Over 7.5 (-110) / Under 7.5 (-110)
Best Bet: Pirates -1.5 Run Line
This Pirates vs Rockies betting preview strongly recommends the Pirates -1.5 Run Line (-135 to -145). The enormous pitching mismatch with elite Skenes dominating a struggling Lorenzen at home in PNC Park sets up Pittsburgh to win by multiple runs. The Rockies face a significant step up in competition here.
Best Bet: Pirates -1.5 runs for 1 unit (BetRivers -139)
Kansas City Royals vs. Chicago White Sox Best Bets and Predictions
The Kansas City Royals (19-22) visit the Chicago White Sox (19-21) for the series opener at Guaranteed Rate Field in Chicago, Illinois. First pitch is scheduled for 7:40 PM EDT. Both teams played yesterday, wrapping up their previous series.
Pitching Matchup: Stephen Kolek vs Erick Fedde
Kansas City Royals send right-hander Stephen Kolek (1-0, 4.50 ERA, 0.67 WHIP in 6.0 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 4.12, xFIP 4.05, xERA 4.35, K/BB% 18% (strong strikeout rate with good early control).
Chicago White Sox counter with right-hander Erick Fedde (0-4, 3.79 ERA, 1.13 WHIP in 38.0 IP). Advanced metrics: FIP 4.25, xFIP 4.18, xERA 4.40, K/BB% 15% (solid command and efficiency at home).
The Royals are a dismal 6-12 on the road, the worst record in baseball. They also rank dead last in almost every offensive category on the road, particularly in the first 5 innings against opposing starters.
The Royals have gone 4-6 in their last 10 games, while the White Sox are 5-5 over the same stretch.
Weather at Guaranteed Rate Field
Cool evening conditions around 58-62°F at first pitch, partly cloudy skies, and light winds (5-10 mph blowing in from left field). Low rain chance, creating a pitcher-friendly environment.
Betting Odds (Consensus)
- Moneyline: Royals -120 to -130 | White Sox +105 to +115
- Run Line: Royals -1.5 (+130 to +140) | White Sox +1.5 (-155 to -165)
- Total (Over/Under): Over 9 (-110) / Under 9 (-110)
Best Bet: White Sox Moneyline
This White Sox vs Royals betting preview strongly recommends the White Sox on the Moneyline (+105 to +115). At home as plus-money underdogs, Chicago gets a competitive pitching matchup with Fedde against Kolek in a favorable park. Kansas City's terrible road performance (6-12, worst in MLB) and anemic offense — especially early in games — make the White Sox strong value here.
Best Bet: White Sox ML for 0.5 unit (FanDuel +106)
Tuesday's Best Bets and Predictions
- Rays ML for 1.0 unit (FanDuel -115)
- Pirates -1.5 runs for 1 unit (BetRivers -139)
- White Sox ML for 0.5 unit (FanDuel +106)
