NBA DFS Picks: DraftKings Showdown Plays and Lineup Strategy for Tuesday, May 26

Break down the best DraftKings Showdown builds for Spurs vs. Thunder Game 5, including Captain picks, value plays, and how San Antonio's defensive adjustments shape the slate.
NBA DFS Picks: DraftKings Showdown Plays and Lineup Strategy for Tuesday, May 26

The Spurs caught lightning in a bottle and evened up the series against the defending champs. I have ideas about how they did it and whether they'll employ the same strategy tonight. It's all in today's article, which focuses on the best DFS builds for Tuesday's DraftKings Showdown contests. We'll begin with a brief introduction to the format for the uninitiated.

For DraftKings Showdown contests, participants are given six positions to fill. While five of them are normal (UTIL) spots, the remaining slot allows for a 1.5x multiplier to be given to the selected player. We typically call it the Captain slot. That's a significant bonus for the selected player, but there is a catch. The player's base salary is also multiplied by 1.5x when used in the multiplier spot. 

The most common mistake made by DFS players is assuming that finding the game's top scorer and placing them in the multiplier is the key to winning. While that strategy can happen occasionally, it's often not the case. The top scorer will usually have a high salary, and the 1.5x sum will restrict your ability to maximize production in the UTIL spots. If a player's base salary is $10,000, it increases to $15,000 under the multiplier, eating up a third of your available salary.

Try our DraftKings NBA Lineup Optimizer to discover more expert recommendations, customize the player pool, set exposure percentage and mass-enter DFS lineups.

NBA Games Today

For the latest spreads and over/unders, visit RotoWire's NBA Odds page. There you can also find player props, futures, picks, articles and sportsbook bonus codes.

So, how did the Spurs pull off a Game 4 beatdown of the Thunder? Look no further than the defense's treatment of Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. Rather than crowding him with double-team schemes at halfcourt, the Spurs aimed to neutralize off-the-ball shooters and only gave the MVP additional attention at the perimeter. Via this method, they were still able to contest his three-point shots while limiting the MVP's assist options. The result was a sharp downtick in production within SGA's supporting cast. Luckily for San Antonio, Gilgeous-Alexander's shot was off throughout the game. Whether the Spurs' strategy can stand up against a proficient shooting night from SGA is an open question, but I would expect them to lean into the most effective defensive setup the Thunder have experienced in the postseason. If SGA beats the single coverage more consistently, the Spurs may be forced to abandon the idea entirely.

Also, the Thunder's on/off-court data against Victor Wembanyama was downright dreadful. After a couple of effective nights against him, the Thunder seemed devoid of answers when he was on the court, and only found a rhythm when he took a seat. The Spurs were exponentially more effective with Wemby in the game, and it's one reason why maximizing exposure to him will be essential for DFS success.

NBA Injury Report Today 

For all the latest updates, visit RotoWire's NBA Injury News page and our comprehensive NBA Injury Report 

OKC- OUT: Ajay Mitchell (calf) QUESTIONABLE: Jalen Williams (hamstring)

While it's prudent to check on Williams' status before game lock, his appearance is unlikely. With both guys out, we should expect more from Jared McCain ($4,200) and Isaiah Joe ($2,800).

Captain (1.5x) Candidates

Victor Wembanyama, SAS (CPTN $19,500, UTIL $13,000)

Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, OKC (CPTN $18,000, UTIL $12,000)

De'Aaron Fox, SAS (CPTN $10,800, UTIL $7,200)

Regardless of who you choose as Captain, Wembanyama and SGA are essential for the majority of your builds. You get an average of $4,750 per slot with SGA at the top, and $4,625 per slot with Wembanyama in the multiplier. Luckily, Mitchell's absence will open up some value at the bottom (see below). I still like Fox as a sneaky multiplier play, as he was able to beat 5x value after a slow start. A Fox/SGA/Wemby build yields a similar shot average as above, with an average of $4,733 for the remaining three spots. The combination of the Spurs' new defensive approach and SGA's ability to exploit it should result in a much better game for the MVP, and I'm inclined to lean in that direction. Taking SGA over Wembanyama only saves us $125, so it may still make sense to take Wembanyama and the inevitable 35-40 minutes he'll receive.

Utility Candidates

All MVP candidates are also recommended for UTIL positions. I will split the options into two groups. With the aforementioned builds in mind, we can fit in one of the following:

Devin Vassell, SAS ($7,000)

Alex Caruso, OKC ($6,400)

Vassell was a borderline Captain option, but I decided to leave him as a utility-only play tonight. He's a better get than Caruso, who fell victim to San Antonio's adjusted defensive approach. I think Mark Daigneault is keenly aware of why things went down the way they did in Game 4, but it may be difficult to write up a way to get Caruso more production if he's being heavily guarded like he was on Sunday. As I said, SGA may be able to force the Spurs out of the new look, but San Antonio's perimeter defense looked hard to beat once they moved to single coverage. These guys are slightly more attainable with a Fox build, but you'll have to go lower in the next group if you're taking Wemby or SGA in the multiplier.

Isaiah Hartenstein, OKC ($4,600)

Jared McCain ($4,200)

Isaiah Joe, OKC ($2,800)

The Thunder will respond to the Spurs' new defensive method, and I think a surprise player will be a byproduct of their approach. While Hartenstein or McCain are great options to finish out a variety of builds, a Wemby or SGA build needs a bargain like Joe to balance out your roster.

Wembanyama/Gilgeous-Alexander/Vassell/Hartenstein/J Williams/Joe

I like this build, although it is a bit heavy on the Thunder. An alternative build with SGA at the top and Fox in for Vassell could look something like this:

Gilgeous-Alexander/Wembanyama/Fox/Vassell/Joe/Kenrich Williams

Williams is little more than a punt here, but you get a slight boost from Fox, who is at roughly the same salary point as Vassell. You'll find a variety of players at similar price points, so it's easy to create several combos between the two groups.

Building a Castle

Once the Spurs committed to single coverage, Stephon Castle was excellent in keeping SGA at bay. My worry with Castle is the amount of energy expended during that task, and the effect it may have on the offensive end. While getting Castle involved is far from impossible, it creates a shaky build. Even if you use Joe, you'll need to use Keldon Johnson and Jaylin Williams to finish out the lineup. It's a risk-reward build, for sure.

Gilgeous-Alexander/Wembanyama/Castle/Joe/K Johnson/J Williams

The author(s) of this article may play in daily fantasy contests including – but not limited to – games that they have provided recommendations or advice on in this article. In the course of playing in these games using their personal accounts, it's possible that they will use players in their lineups or other strategies that differ from the recommendations they have provided above. The recommendations in this article do not necessarily reflect the views of RotoWire.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jeff has provided sports content for numerous sports outlets and has played fantasy sports since scores had to be tabulated via newspaper. He started working with RotoWire in 2017. Originally from South Carolina, he's a lifelong Clemson fan now enjoying the sun in Los Angeles.
RotoWire Logo

Continue the Conversation

Join the RotoWire Discord group to hear from our experts and other NBA fans.

Top News

Tools

MLB Draft Kit Logo

MLB Draft Kit

Fantasy Tools

Don’t miss a beat. Check out our 2026 MLB Fantasy Baseball rankings.

Related Stories