Weekly Pitcher Rankings: The Worst Ever?

Weekly Pitcher Rankings: The Worst Ever?

This article is part of our Weekly Pitcher Rankings series.

Records are kept on everything nowadays, so someone must know for sure, but we might be looking at the weakest slate of two-start pitchers ever. Yes, ever.

This could be a week to float in a third closer, or even a dominant middle reliever to offer ratio support while adding some punchouts. Speaking of which, strikeouts in May were the fewest since June 2018. Maybe it's happenstance, or maybe batters are making adjustments. That said, Friday's ledger generated the fourth-most homers on a single day in history.

Just as you think you know the answer, they change the question.

Speaking of questions, I'm always happy to address queries below, though please direct those involving scheduling to the Probable Pitchers page.

UPDATED: Monday June 6 1:40 AM ET

Week of June 6 - 12

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPComments
1Kyle WrightATLOAK, PITTwo soft home dates
2Nestor Cortes Jr.NYY@MIN, CHCNo signs of slowing down
3Corbin BurnesMILPHI 
4Justin VerlanderHOUSEAStrikeouts up, but so are homers
5Carlos RodonSFCOL, LAD 
6Shane BieberCLETEXVelo down, but revamping approach
7Joe MusgroveSDCOL 
8Sandy AlcantaraMIAWAS 
9Max FriedATLPIT 
10Cal QuantrillCLETEX, OAKTwo lesser lineups at home
11Alek ManoahTOR@KC 
12Shane McClanahanTBSTL 
13Michael KopechCWSLAD, TEX 
14Triston McKenzieCLEOAK 
15

Records are kept on everything nowadays, so someone must know for sure, but we might be looking at the weakest slate of two-start pitchers ever. Yes, ever.

This could be a week to float in a third closer, or even a dominant middle reliever to offer ratio support while adding some punchouts. Speaking of which, strikeouts in May were the fewest since June 2018. Maybe it's happenstance, or maybe batters are making adjustments. That said, Friday's ledger generated the fourth-most homers on a single day in history.

Just as you think you know the answer, they change the question.

Speaking of questions, I'm always happy to address queries below, though please direct those involving scheduling to the Probable Pitchers page.

UPDATED: Monday June 6 1:40 AM ET

Week of June 6 - 12

Mixed

RankPitcherTMOPPComments
1Kyle WrightATLOAK, PITTwo soft home dates
2Nestor Cortes Jr.NYY@MIN, CHCNo signs of slowing down
3Corbin BurnesMILPHI 
4Justin VerlanderHOUSEAStrikeouts up, but so are homers
5Carlos RodonSFCOL, LAD 
6Shane BieberCLETEXVelo down, but revamping approach
7Joe MusgroveSDCOL 
8Sandy AlcantaraMIAWAS 
9Max FriedATLPIT 
10Cal QuantrillCLETEX, OAKTwo lesser lineups at home
11Alek ManoahTOR@KC 
12Shane McClanahanTBSTL 
13Michael KopechCWSLAD, TEX 
14Triston McKenzieCLEOAK 
15Framber ValdezHOUMIA 
16Gerrit ColeNYY@MIN 
17Cristian JavierHOUSEA, MIA 
18Aaron NolaPHI@MIL 
19Zack WheelerPHIARI 
20Blake SnellSDNYM, COL 
21Sean ManaeaSDNYM 
22Lucas GiolitoCWSTEX 
23Kevin GausmanTOR@DET 
24Julio UriasLAD@SF 
25Tarik SkubalDET@PIT 
26MacKenzie GoreSDCOL 
27Jordan MontgomeryNYYCHC 
28Yu DarvishSDNYM 
29Pablo LopezMIA@HOU 
30Logan WebbSFLADStrikeouts on the rise
31Frankie MontasOAK@CLENot letting team context affect performance
32Tyler AndersonLAD@CWSI call him Tyer after taking the L
33Tony GonsolinLAD@CWS 
34Graham AshcraftCINARI, @STLCould use better offspeed pitches, but encouraging start
35Clayton KershawLAD@SFSlated to return
36Nathan EovaldiBOS@LAA 
37Adam WainwrightSTLCIN 
38Walker BuehlerLAD@SF 
39Luis GarciaHOUMIA 
40Robbie RaySEA@HOU, BOSTough pair while struggling with command and control
41Edward CabreraMIAWAS, @HOU 
42Drew RasmussenTBSTL 
43Zach PlesacCLEOAK 
44Luis SeverinoNYYCHC 
45Logan GilbertSEA@HOU 
46Mike ClevingerSDCOL 
47Miles MikolasSTL@TB 
48Luis CastilloCIN@STLShoving, and it's not that warm yet
49Garrett WhitlockBOS@LAA, @SEA6 IP with no strikeouts last time out
50Michael WachaBOS@LAA, @SEA 
51Martin PerezTEX@CWS 
52Ian AndersonATLOAK 
53Jon GrayTEX@CLE, @CWSWould like to see what he can do when healthy for an extended run
54Jameson TaillonNYY@MINOnly four homers allowed in 58 IP
55Alex WoodSFCOL 
56Stephen StrasburgWAS@MIAShort term outlook after TOS often solid, long term is sketchy
57Konnor PilkingtonCLETEX, OAKTop pickup this week if available
58Carlos CarrascoNYM@SD, @LAA 
59Rich HillBOS@SEA 
60Zac GallenARI@PHI 
61Chris BassittNYM@SD 
62Zach EflinPHI@MIL 
63Shohei OhtaniLAABOS 
64Tyler WellsBAL@KC 
65Dakota HudsonSTL@TB, CIN 
66Devin SmeltzerMINTB 
67Noah SyndergaardLAABOS, NYMFastball down 3 mph, slider down 6 mph
68Nick PivettaBOS@LAA 
69George KirbySEABOS 
70Bailey OberMINNYY, TB 
71Jose BerriosTOR@DETTrack record too good to be this bad
72Michael LorenzenLAANYM 
73Alex CobbSFCOL 
74Dylan CeaseCWSLAD 
75Roansy ContrerasPIT@ATL 
76Patrick SandovalLAANYM 
77Mix 12 Reliever   
78German MarquezCOL@SF, @SD 
79Corey KluberTBSTL, @MIN 
80Eric LauerMIL@WAS 
81Jakob JunisSFLAD 
82Joe RyanMINNYY 
83Chad KuhlCOL@SD 
84Josiah GrayWAS@MIA 
85Brandon WoodruffMIL@WAS 
86Charlie MortonATLPIT 
87Mix 15 Reliever   
88Marco GonzalesSEABOS 
89Dane DunningTEX@CLE 
90Spencer StriderATLPIT 
91David PetersonNYM@LAA 
92Austin GomberCOL@SFUh oh, road start in Oracle Park. What could possibly go wrong?
93Adrian HouserMILPHI 
94Jose QuintanaPITDET, @ATL 
95Shane BazTB@MIN 
96Jose UrquidyHOUSEA 
97Brad KellerKCTOR, BAL 
98Keegan ThompsonCHC@BAL 
99Marcus StromanCHC@BAL 
100Ranger SuarezPHI@MIL, ARI 
101Mike MinorCINARI 
102Alex FaedoDET@PIT 
103Kyle GibsonPHIARI 
104Brady SingerKCTOR 
105Taijuan WalkerNYM@SD 
106Reid DetmersLAABOS 
107Tyler GilbertARI@CIN, @PHI 
108Trevor RogersMIAWASSo befuddling, but nothing exhibits reason for optimism
109Aaron AshbyMIL@WAS 
110Steven MatzSTLCIN 
111Mitch WhiteLAD@CWS 
112Merrill KellyARI@CIN 
113Madison BumgarnerARI@CIN, @PHI 
114Tyler MahleCINARI 
115Glenn OttoTEX@CWS 
116Kyle FreelandCOL@SD 
117Chris FlexenSEA@HOU 
118Jason AlexanderMILPHI 
119Dylan BundyMINTB 
120Kris BubicKCBAL 
121Yusei KikuchiTOR@KC 
122Paul BlackburnOAK@CLE 
123JT BrubakerPIT@ATL 
124Mitch KellerPITDET 
125Matt SwarmerCHC@NYY 
126Hunter GreeneCINARI, @STL 
127Trevor WilliamsNYM@LAA 
128James KaprielianOAK@CLE 
129Ryan FeltnerCOL@SD 
130Ross StriplingTOR@KC, @DET 
131Johnny CuetoCWSLAD 
132Zach ThompsonPIT@ATL 
133Chase SilsethLAABOS 
134Jonathan HeasleyKCBAL 
135Antonio SenzatelaCOL@SF 
136Kyle HendricksCHC@NYY 
137Daniel LynchKCTOR, BAL 
138Cole IrvinOAK@ATL, @CLE 
139Chris ArcherMINNYY 
140Dean KremerBAL@KC 
141Zach DaviesARI@CIN 
142Justin SteeleCHC@NYY 
143Bruce ZimmermannBAL@KC 
144Jordan LylesBALCHC 
145Beau BrieskeDETTOR 
146Kyle BradishBALCHC, @KC 
147Erick FeddeWASMIL 
148Jared KoenigOAK@ATL 
149Braxton GarrettMIA@HOU 
150Joan AdonWAS@MIA, MIL 
151Patrick CorbinWASMIL 
152Zack ThompsonSTL@TB 
153Davis MartinCWSTEX 
154Rony GarciaDETTOR 
155Ryan YarbroughTB@MIN 
156Taylor HearnTEX@CLE 
157Elvin RodriguezDETTOR 

American League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Nestor Cortes Jr.NYY@MIN, CHCNo signs of slowing down
2Justin VerlanderHOUSEAStrikeouts up, but so are homers
3Shane BieberCLETEXVelo down, but revamping approach
4Cal QuantrillCLETEX, OAKTwo lesser lineups at home
5Alek ManoahTOR@KC 
6Shane McClanahanTBSTL 
7Michael KopechCWSLAD, TEX 
8Triston McKenzieCLEOAK 
9Framber ValdezHOUMIA 
10Gerrit ColeNYY@MIN 
11Cristian JavierHOUSEA, MIA 
12Lucas GiolitoCWSTEX 
13Kevin GausmanTOR@DET 
14Tarik SkubalDET@PIT 
15Jordan MontgomeryNYYCHC 
16Frankie MontasOAK@CLENot letting team context affect performance
17Nathan EovaldiBOS@LAA 
18Luis GarciaHOUMIA 
19Robbie RaySEA@HOU, BOSTough pair while struggling with command and control
20Drew RasmussenTBSTL 
21Zach PlesacCLEOAK 
22Luis SeverinoNYYCHC 
23Logan GilbertSEA@HOU 
24Garrett WhitlockBOS@LAA, @SEA6 IP with no strikeouts last time out
25Michael WachaBOS@LAA, @SEA 
26Martin PerezTEX@CWS 
27Jon GrayTEX@CLE, @CWSWould like to see what he can do when healthy for an extended run
28Jameson TaillonNYY@MINOnly four homers allowed in 58 IP
29Konnor PilkingtonCLETEX, OAKTop pickup this week if available
30Rich HillBOS@SEA 
31Shohei OhtaniLAABOS 
32Tyler WellsBAL@KC 
33Devin SmeltzerMINTB 
34Noah SyndergaardLAABOS, NYMFastball down 3 mph, slider down 6 mph
35Nick PivettaBOS@LAA 
36George KirbySEABOS 
37Bailey OberMINNYY, TB 
38Jose BerriosTOR@DETTrack record too good to be this bad
39Michael LorenzenLAANYM 
40Dylan CeaseCWSLAD 
41Patrick SandovalLAANYM 
42Corey KluberTBSTL, @MIN 
43Joe RyanMINNYY 
44Marco GonzalesSEABOS 
45Dane DunningTEX@CLE 
46Shane BazTB@MIN 
47Jose UrquidyHOUSEA 
48Brad KellerKCTOR, BAL 
49Alex FaedoDET@PIT 
50Brady SingerKCTOR 
51Reid DetmersLAABOS 
52AL Reliever   
53Glenn OttoTEX@CWS 
54Chris FlexenSEA@HOU 
55Dylan BundyMINTB 
56Kris BubicKCBAL 
57Yusei KikuchiTOR@KC 
58Paul BlackburnOAK@CLE 
59James KaprielianOAK@CLE 
60Ross StriplingTOR@KC, @DET 
61Johnny CuetoCWSLAD 
62Chase SilsethLAABOS 
63Jonathan HeasleyKCBAL 
64Daniel LynchKCTOR, BAL 
65Cole IrvinOAK@ATL, @CLE 
66Chris ArcherMINNYY 
67Dean KremerBAL@KC 
68Bruce ZimmermannBAL@KC 
69Jordan LylesBALCHC 
70Beau BrieskeDETTOR 
71Kyle BradishBALCHC, @KC 
72Jared KoenigOAK@ATL 
73Davis MartinCWSTEX 
74Rony GarciaDETTOR 
75Ryan YarbroughTB@MIN 
76Taylor HearnTEX@CLE 
77Elvin RodriguezDETTOR 

National League

RankPitcherTMOPPComment
1Kyle WrightATLOAK, PITTwo soft home dates
2Corbin BurnesMILPHI 
3Carlos RodonSFCOL, LAD 
4Joe MusgroveSDCOL 
5Sandy AlcantaraMIAWAS 
6Max FriedATLPIT 
7Aaron NolaPHI@MIL 
8Zack WheelerPHIARI 
9Blake SnellSDNYM, COL 
10Sean ManaeaSDNYM 
11Julio UriasLAD@SF 
12MacKenzie GoreSDCOL 
13Yu DarvishSDNYM 
14Pablo LopezMIA@HOU 
15Logan WebbSFLADStrikeouts on the rise
16Tyler AndersonLAD@CWSI call him Tyer after taking the L
17Tony GonsolinLAD@CWS 
18Graham AshcraftCINARI, @STLCould use better offspeed pitches, but encouraging start
19Clayton KershawLAD@SFSlated to return
20Adam WainwrightSTLCIN 
21Walker BuehlerLAD@SF 
22Edward CabreraMIAWAS, @HOU 
23Mike ClevingerSDCOL 
24Miles MikolasSTL@TB 
25Luis CastilloCIN@STLShoving, and it's not that warm yet
26Ian AndersonATLOAK 
27Alex WoodSFCOL 
28Stephen StrasburgWAS@MIAShort term outlook after TOS often solid, long term is sketchy
29Carlos CarrascoNYM@SD, @LAA 
30Zac GallenARI@PHI 
31Chris BassittNYM@SD 
32Zach EflinPHI@MIL 
33Dakota HudsonSTL@TB, CIN 
34Alex CobbSFCOL 
35Roansy ContrerasPIT@ATL 
36German MarquezCOL@SF, @SD 
37Eric LauerMIL@WAS 
38Jakob JunisSFLAD 
39Chad KuhlCOL@SD 
40Josiah GrayWAS@MIA 
41Brandon WoodruffMIL@WAS 
42Charlie MortonATLPIT 
43Spencer StriderATLPIT 
44David PetersonNYM@LAA 
45Austin GomberCOL@SFUh oh, road start in Oracle Park. What could possibly go wrong?
46Adrian HouserMILPHI 
47Jose QuintanaPITDET, @ATL 
48Keegan ThompsonCHC@BAL 
49Marcus StromanCHC@BAL 
50Ranger SuarezPHI@MIL, ARI 
51Mike MinorCINARI 
52Kyle GibsonPHIARI 
53Taijuan WalkerNYM@SD 
54Tyler GilbertARI@CIN, @PHI 
55Trevor RogersMIAWASSo befuddling, but nothing exhibits reason for optimism
56NL Reliever   
57Aaron AshbyMIL@WAS 
58Steven MatzSTLCIN 
59Mitch WhiteLAD@CWS 
60Merrill KellyARI@CIN 
61Madison BumgarnerARI@CIN, @PHI 
62Tyler MahleCINARI 
63Kyle FreelandCOL@SD 
64Jason AlexanderMILPHI 
65JT BrubakerPIT@ATL 
66Mitch KellerPITDET 
67Matt SwarmerCHC@NYY 
68Hunter GreeneCINARI, @STL 
69Trevor WilliamsNYM@LAA 
70Ryan FeltnerCOL@SD 
71Zach ThompsonPIT@ATL 
72Antonio SenzatelaCOL@SF 
73Kyle HendricksCHC@NYY 
74Zach DaviesARI@CIN 
75Justin SteeleCHC@NYY 
76Erick FeddeWASMIL 
77Braxton GarrettMIA@HOU 
78Joan AdonWAS@MIA, MIL 
79Patrick CorbinWASMIL 
80Zack ThompsonSTL@TB 

Want to Read More?
Subscribe to RotoWire to see the full article.

We reserve some of our best content for our paid subscribers. Plus, if you choose to subscribe you can discuss this article with the author and the rest of the RotoWire community.

Get Instant Access To This Article Get Access To This Article
RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Todd Zola
Todd has been writing about fantasy baseball since 1997. He won NL Tout Wars and Mixed LABR in 2016 as well as a multi-time league winner in the National Fantasy Baseball Championship. Todd is now setting his sights even higher: The Rotowire Staff League. Lord Zola, as he's known in the industry, won the 2013 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Article of the Year award and was named the 2017 FSWA Fantasy Baseball Writer of the Year. Todd is a five-time FSWA awards finalist.
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez
Offseason Deep Dives: Reynaldo Lopez
Offseason Deep Dives: Hunter Greene
Offseason Deep Dives: Hunter Greene
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
Farm Futures: November Dynasty Mailbag!
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers
All-Bust Fantasy Team: Relief Pitchers